Retirees Regret This Housing Decision All the Time
Executive Summary
Thinking about downsizing in retirement? The answer might not be as obvious as it seems. While selling your home can unlock equity and reduce expenses, it can also disrupt your lifestyle in ways you didn’t expect. This blog explores the real risks and rewards of downsizing, why so many retirees end up regretting the move, and how to test the decision before you commit.
Want to watch an in-depth exploration of this topic?
Check out this video on my YouTube channel, @SavvySteward: Retirees Regret This Housing Decision All the Time
Take the free “How Much Do I Need To Retire” Quiz here:
https://secure.kingsview.com/keith-savvy-steward-quiz-youtube#q1
Retirees Regret This Housing Decision All the Time
Downsizing is one of those retirement decisions that sounds simple — until you start looking at the details. On paper, it can look like a clear win, but in real life, the trade-offs aren’t always obvious. From the dollars and cents to how you spend your days, the choice to move into a smaller home can reshape more than just your floor plan. Before you call a realtor, it’s worth looking at the whole picture.
1. What are the financial pros and cons of downsizing in retirement?
At first glance, downsizing sounds like a clear financial win. You might unlock equity that’s been sitting in your home for years, reduce your monthly bills, and simplify your financial picture in retirement. Lower property taxes, smaller utility bills, and fewer maintenance needs can all contribute to more breathing room in your budget.
But the math isn’t always so clean. Smaller homes often cost more per square foot, especially in competitive markets. That’s because you still need the expensive parts—kitchens, bathrooms, HVAC systems—but they’re spread across less square footage. Add in the rising demand from first-time buyers and investors, and the price tag might not shrink as much as you’d expect.
Factor in moving costs, realtor commissions, renovations, and upgrades, and you could easily eat into the equity you planned to capture. If your goal is to simplify and reduce your financial burden, you’ll need to run the numbers carefully. Downsizing might offer financial flexibility—but only if the margins truly work in your favor.
2. How does lifestyle play into the downsizing decision?
Financial considerations are just one part of the picture. Downsizing also changes how you live day to day. For some, that change feels like freedom—less house to clean, fewer responsibilities, and the ability to lock the door and travel without a second thought.
But not everyone is ready to trade space for simplicity. If you love hosting holidays, having a spare room for grandkids, or simply enjoy the comfort of space, a smaller home might feel limiting. If you relocate, downsizing can also mean giving up long-time routines, relationships, and even your neighborhood support system.
This is why lifestyle alignment matters. It’s not just about cost savings—it’s about whether the new version of home fits your day-to-day life.
3. What should you evaluate before making a move?
Start with the “why.” Are you hoping to simplify your life? Move closer to family? Free up money for travel or experiences? Or do you feel like it’s just what retirees are “supposed” to do?
Clarity around your motivation is key. Without it, it’s easy to make a housing decision that doesn’t truly serve your goals.
Then get practical. How do you currently use your space? What would be hardest to give up? Think about things like:
- Hosting family events
- Garage space and storage
- Proximity to your faith community or doctors
- Familiarity with your neighborhood
You’re not just choosing a home. You’re choosing a rhythm of life.
4. How can you avoid regret if you decide to downsize?
Try before you commit. Spend a few weeks renting a smaller place in the area you’re considering. This real-world preview gives you insight that no spreadsheet or realtor pitch can replicate. You’ll get to experience the new routine and gauge how much (or how little) you miss your current space.
Also, don’t rush the decision. Just because the market is hot or your friends are moving doesn’t mean it’s the right time for you. Move on your own timeline—when it makes sense for your life and finances.
5. What’s the real goal behind a housing decision in retirement?
Your home is more than an asset. It’s the backdrop of your life.
The goal isn’t just less space, it’s more life. You want a housing setup that frees you to live the way you want, both now and in the future. That means choosing a plan that aligns with your priorities, supports your lifestyle, and respects your financial reality.
When stewardship leads the decision—not trends, or pressure—you’re much more likely to land in a place that feels right for the long haul.
Downsizing can be a powerful move, but only when it’s the right move. Before you make a change, take the time to get clear on your goals, your needs, and the trade-offs you’re truly willing to make.
Your home isn’t just where you live, it’s how you live. Make the decision that supports the life you want.
Contact Information
Keith Demetriades, CFP®, CKA®
For more information or to start a conversation about your financial future, contact Keith at (806) 223-1105 or visit Kingsview Partners.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this blog is for educational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Please consult a qualified financial advisor to discuss your specific situation and needs. Past performance does not indicate future results, and all investments carry risks, including potential loss of principal. Any financial product or strategy references are purely illustrative and should not be construed as endorsements or recommendations.
